Wednesday, April 9, 2008

Immigration and Day Laborers: Oregonian 3/2/08

IMMIGRATION

Sunday, March 02, 2008
ELLIOTT YOUNG

The Portland's City Council's public hearing on Wednesday to consider funding a day labor center will bring the rancorous national immigration debate right to the heart of our city.

Whichever side you fall on, we all must recognize that immigrants are a boon to our city's and our nation's economy. We can choose to harass these workers and push them underground where unscrupulous employers can exploit them or we can treat them with respect and dignity and help them to achieve the American Dream.

We all know that some of these day laborers are in this country illegally, but labeling these people "illegals" stigmatizes them as violent criminals. Yet there is no evidence that immigrants commit higher rates of crime than do those born in the United States. In fact, the data on incarceration rates show just the opposite -- that native-born men between 18 and 39 commit crime at a rate 3.5 times as high as foreign-born men.

Anti-immigrant groups propagate myths that undocumented immigrants drag down the economy, bilk our social welfare system, remain culturally insulated and frequently commit violent crime.

Nothing could be further from the truth. Even President Bush's Council of Economic Advisors, a group that can hardly be accused of liberalism, concludes in its June 2007 report that "U.S. natives benefit from immigration." According to the council's study, immigrants improve economic productivity, complement rather than replace native laborers, assimilate quickly, have lower crime rates than natives and pay far more in taxes than they draw from public social services.

In addition, Giovanni Peri, a labor economist from the University of California, Davis, has shown that immigrants not only help general economic productivity, but they also benefit American workers by shifting them into more skilled and higher-paid jobs.

The economic data notwithstanding, blaming foreigners for economic distress is an old story in our country. Nativists in the mid-19th century targeted Irish Catholics for their supposed disloyalty, anti-Asian exclusionists accused Chinese workers of stealing American jobs; and in the early 20th century, politicians whipped up anti-communist fears and arrested Italian labor organizers in the Red Scare. A century ago, trade unions were part of this sad history of anti-immigrant racism and xenophobia. Today unions have the chance to do the right thing.

The real reason why the middle and working classes in Oregon and across America have suffered has nothing to do with the Mexican immigrant standing on the corner waiting for work. Rather, our tax system has increased inequality over the past quarter-century by shifting the tax burden from the wealthiest 1 percent to the backs of poor and middle-income earners. In 2000, more than half of the corporations in Oregon with payrolls greater than $2 million paid the state's minimum income tax of just $10.

The politicians who supported free trade policies, corporate welfare, tax breaks for the rich and a half-trillion-dollar war debacle have gotten us into this economic mess. Until we can elect a president who will advocate a sane immigration policy, let's be decent and humane to the immigrant workers among us, for their sake as well as ours.

Elliott Young is an associate professor of history at Lewis & Clark College who works on the history of immigration from Mexico to the United States.